Why Staffing Agencies Struggle Despite Better Technology

Daphne wide Why Staffing Agencies Struggle Despite Better Technology
 Show Notes

In this episode of Recruiting Evolution, host Kortney Harmon welcomes Daphne Phalon, a staffing industry veteran and consultant, to explore why investments in staffing agency technology aren’t always translating into better recruiting results.

Daphne shares how disconnected workflows, misleading activity metrics, and declining client relationships can quietly undermine profitability. She also reveals how one staffing firm discovered that 85% of its open job orders were no longer viable, exposing a much deeper operational problem than leadership initially suspected.

The conversation examines why recruiters need stronger coaching, how to identify revenue warning signs before they affect the bottom line, and why successful staffing firms use technology to support human relationships rather than replace them.

For staffing leaders evaluating their processes, Daphne offers a practical starting point: question the data, examine existing tools, and focus on what actually drives placements and profitability.
_________

Follow Daphne Phalon on LinkedIn: LinkedIn | Daphne
Learn more about Daphne’s consulting company here
Follow Crelate on LinkedIn: Crelate
Want to learn more about Crelate? Book a demo here
Subscribe to our newsletter: Recruiting Evolution

Transcription:

Daphne Phalon [00:00:00]:
Honestly, if I’m being perfectly honest, I don’t think that today’s recruiters necessarily know how to actually recruit. They know how to use a lot of technology. They know how to keyword search a job description and parse a resume, but they’re not really recruiting.

Kortney Harmon [00:00:19]:
The talent industry isn’t waiting, and neither are the people building it. Talent is the business. Evolution is the advantage. Welcome to The Recruiting Evolution. I’m your host, Kortney Harmon. We’re getting into the ideas, technology, and relationships moving the talent industry forward with the people doing the work. What’s changing, what’s working, and what it means for your businesses. Here’s where the evolution happens.

Kortney Harmon [00:00:45]:
Let’s get into today’s episode. Welcome back to The Recruiting Evolution. The podcast where we deep dive into the future of talent hiring and the changing world of work. I’m your host, Kortney Harmon, and here we don’t just talk about recruiting as it is today. We’re exploring how it’s evolving, how you can stay ahead. Each episode, we’re going to bring industry leaders like Daphne and forward thinkers to challenge old assumptions and shed new light on what’s next. So today we are joined by someone who’s seen the industry from all angles. We’ll be diving in where she’s seen things, where she thinks we’re headed, and how we truly evolve with it.

Kortney Harmon [00:01:33]:
So with that being said, Daphne, thank you so much for taking the time to spend with me this evening or this morning on this Monday afternoon.

Daphne Phalon [00:01:42]:
Happy to be here. Thank you so much for having me. I appreciate it.

Kortney Harmon [00:01:45]:
I enjoyed our conversation. We actually talked about 2 weeks ago and really looking at your history, kind of where you’ve been, what you’re doing today. You’ve spent 25 years in staffing and now you’re in consulting with those firms across the industry. So let’s start with why you believe what you believe. I know we talked about operations and staffing is failing in 2026. So help me figure out why. Why do you believe that? What do you think’s going on? Help me dive into why you think that.

Daphne Phalon [00:02:17]:
It’s an interesting time, actually. I’m seeing operations struggle in all industry, like all staffing sectors over and over. And it feels a bit like a paradox, like the staffing industry has never had more technology or tools at its fingertips. And yet revenue delivery, placement quality, recruiter productivity seems to be declining at a lot of firms. I believe the root cause is that we’ve sort of Confused motion and activity with momentum. And we want more tools. You and I talked a little bit about like the shiny object, like we want that. Every demo is like, yes, of course I need that.

Daphne Phalon [00:03:03]:
We want more tools, we want more activity, we want more automation, but the result is often less time to actually do recruiting and actually connect with the candidates and with the clients, which is the heart of our industry. And in many cases, it’s almost like staffing companies are struggling because they have too much technology. They just keep buying more and layering it on top of itself, and they’ve forgotten how to actually recruit.

Kortney Harmon [00:03:33]:
Do you think they feel like they need it because they see other people using it, or do you think they don’t know how to apply it the correct way? We talked about this, but I’m curious your stance on where it’s missing in the theory of what’s good up here.

Daphne Phalon [00:03:49]:
I think it’s a little bit of both actually, because I think there’s definitely that FOMO in the industry. Like we are all like, we have to get this because if we don’t, XYZ will happen to us. So we have this serious fear of missing out on something. But I also think staffing people by nature are people people. We’re not necessarily hardwired to be technology implementers, and we oftentimes run really thin. So we don’t have somebody just waiting around for a project to implement the new latest and greatest. So I do regularly see agencies that have bought all sorts of tools and they’ve maybe half implemented them. They’ve brought the technology to the table.

Daphne Phalon [00:04:38]:
They’ve done the implementation session or gotten it to talk with their ATS, but then they don’t really know how to use it or how to use it effectively to help augment their team. And so as a result, it just kind of goes by the wayside or goes wasted. And that’s definitely cutting into profitability as well.

Kortney Harmon [00:05:00]:
So what does it look like? You just kind of described some of it. I’m sure there’s much more. What does it look like when you walk into one of these firms? What are they reaching out to you for? What are they saying? Help me, help me, waving the white flag. And then how are— what does it look like?

Daphne Phalon [00:05:14]:
I’ll give you a little preview of a story that I want to do a little deeper later on. Earlier this year, I walked into a staffing company. The leadership team brought me to the table. They had a problem. What struck me right out of the gate was that the entire team was lockstep. They knew exactly what the problem was. They had plenty of jobs to work on. The recruiters weren’t delivering.

Daphne Phalon [00:05:39]:
And therefore, it must either be that their software wasn’t working, their applicant tracking system wasn’t working, or they needed all new recruiters. In retrospect, the sheer fact that they were all nodding and agreeing probably should have been the biggest red flag right there, because that rarely happens. Usually there’s— Some dissenters, but they all agreed. They all agreed that this was the problem, that they had plenty of jobs and they just needed to figure out a faster way to fill them. But what I found when we dug in was something completely different. And I promise, like, we’ll get, we’ll get a deeper dive into that as we go a little bit further, but it, it’s the clearest example that I have that shows That sometimes leadership is just too trusting of data and they’re not asking the right questions and they’re forgetting how to actually recruit.

Kortney Harmon [00:06:35]:
Very interesting. I can’t wait to learn more about this story. I’ll continue to play along just because I want the full experience. So, let’s talk about, you talked about recruiters. They’re on the floor, they have the heartbeat of the business, they know what their candidates are saying. So, let’s talk about what’s happening there. Are recruiters, are they just not working hard enough? Are they spinning cycles? Are they— obviously this industry has changed a bit. Talk to me about that.

Kortney Harmon [00:07:01]:
What is really happening?

Daphne Phalon [00:07:03]:
Yeah, I definitely wanna be very clear that I do not think recruiters are lazy, and I think many of them are working harder than they ever have, despite all these tools that are being purchased and thrown at them to help make their life easier. Honestly, a lot of recruiters are just overwhelmed. They’re undertrained and they’re being slowly conditioned, maybe even it’s picking up pace, where they’re being conditioned away from the behaviors that made past recruiters really effective at making that perfect job match and seeing the connection between the job description, the role that was really truly open with their client, and the candidate’s background, they’re being conditioned away from that. And the reason I say that is that when we think about the disruption cycle of change, disruption has a cost to it. And I think sometimes we forget about that. But years ago, we’d get an occasional update by Windows. We’d all get the same update. It was every couple of years.

Daphne Phalon [00:08:11]:
We’d all gripe and moan about it, and we’d get on board. We’d kind of move past it. But there was a disruption, but we actually had time to feel that it was a disruption. So we would kvitz about it together. And that was the same with applicant tracking systems. It was like once a year, there’d be some big update or some new product release or coming soon, it’s on the roadmap, and you’d wait with anticipation. But now it’s like daily. Now I feel like every single day, there’s some new update.

Daphne Phalon [00:08:41]:
There’s some little thing that’s popping up in the corner of your screen telling you what’s new today. Managers, like we talked about with the shiny object, they’re buying technology and new tools faster than they ever have. There’s more of them available, and it becomes commonplace for the recruiters to just constantly be chasing, trying to learn it. I said a minute ago, recruiters aren’t always technology people. They’re people people. And so I’ve seen firsthand staff that worked for me that were exceptionally good recruiters. They could see that connection that no one else could see. And I, and it’s kind of awesome when you see it happen and you see somebody that on paper didn’t look like they were gonna be a perfect fit, but then sure enough, they peel the onion a different way and they find this perfect fit and everybody’s happy.

Daphne Phalon [00:09:34]:
But those people weren’t always the ones that could keep up with this pace of technology. And so, I think we’re also seeing some really good people that could have— that had the potential to be really great recruiters, and they’re getting kind of filtered out because they can’t keep up with logging their metrics or using the new texting platform the way everybody else is doing it. And so, I feel like the disruption time of retraining people or bringing in something new or figuring it out how it works or where does it fit in my cycle? That’s really been a challenge. And one of the other things that I’ve noticed is that the best recruiters I’ve known throughout my entire career, regardless of which company I was working with or what my role was, the best recruiters were the people that had set rhythms and they managed their desk to rhythms, whether it was call blocks, relationship check-ins, follow-up routines. They all had those rhythms. And the bombardment of technology, and I, I sound like I’m being like a naysayer of technology. I love technology. I, I’m a total techie nerd and I love learning new things, but the bombardment and the churn that’s coming at people these days is definitely disrupting those rhythms that from seeing it happen for 20-plus years of seeing how the most effective recruiters were the ones that had those rhythms.

Daphne Phalon [00:11:04]:
And yet those rhythms are being disrupted now at almost a daily pace, if not, maybe it’s weekly, but it’s pretty regularly. And they’re having a hard time, I think, getting back to what a rhythm looks like. So, I don’t for one second think that recruiters are being lazy or that they’re just not bought in. I think they’re kind of drowning at this point.

Kortney Harmon [00:11:27]:
And it’s at cost of those relationships, it sounds like, from what you’re saying. I think I’ve seen it too. But it’s like when they get a minute to breathe, they get their minute to breathe, yet they’re learning the new AI tool or the latest update or the next thing to make them move faster. In reality, this is a speed game. We all know recruiting is about speed, but it’s not at cost of the relationship. And when we’re moving faster, at what time do we catch up?

Daphne Phalon [00:11:55]:
Yeah, at night, at night, on the weekends. And that’s what makes it so tempting to just be like, I’ll just send a text out to 150 people. That’s not relationship. It’s not.

Kortney Harmon [00:12:07]:
I agree. So, do you think, so that cycle that is being disrupted, do you think that’s also impacting, I’m assuming, I don’t want to put words in your mouth, do you think that’s assuming the candidate conversation to deepen those relationships at all?

Daphne Phalon [00:12:21]:
Oh yeah. I think the candidate conversation has become a victim in the whole new world of recruiting. And I think the death of the candidate experience or the candidate conversation is probably one of the top things that worries me most for our industry. And I say that because I think candidate outreach has largely been reduced to text blasts, auto-generated templates, and chatbots that are doing all the screening. And the part that really gets me is that even when You send out all of these things and you’re hoping that, I don’t know, we get a 5% return rate on it, right? Even when candidates do respond, oftentimes their responses aren’t even being seen by a human being because they’re getting kind of cataloged and dumped back into the applicant tracking system, never to be seen by human eyes. And, you know, I think chatbots are super interesting, and I think that they, on a screening front side of things to like check the boxes of like, is this a good fit for you? Is this, you know, in those types of basic, basic screening, I think there’s a mechanism there that’s helpful, but I don’t think it replaces conversation. And this year, more than ever, I’ve seen that intimate exploratory conversation between a recruiter and a candidate, just, you know, the ones like where they’re like, You’re talking with the candidate and you’re trying to figure out, like, what does this candidate really want? And what are they afraid of? What’s going to make them say yes? And what’s absolutely going to make them say no? And how do you create urgency without, like, drilling down on pressure? And those conversations, they’re largely gone. It’s very superficial.

Daphne Phalon [00:14:12]:
And the conversations are just, get off the— get the information you need. Did you like it? Did it go good? Yeah, great. Move on. And check a box on your metrics. And I think that those conversations are really where really good recruiters can fine-tune that candidate experience, really figure out with precision, are they the right fit for this? Could they be a right fit for something in the future? Are they somebody that can generate referrals? Am I asking for referrals? Honestly, if I’m being perfectly honest, I don’t think that today’s recruiters necessarily know how to actually recruit. They know how to use a lot of technology. They know how to keyword search a job description and parse a resume, but they’re not really recruiting. I just recently did a LinkedIn post about post and pray.

Daphne Phalon [00:15:07]:
It’s not a strategy. Posting a job and waiting for somebody to make it through the filter, isn’t recruiting, and text blasts is not recruiting either. Recruiters today are just kind of fishing with a dragnet and hoping that they happen to come across a school of fish and drag in the perfect one, whereas real recruiting is more like knowing exactly what kind of fish you want, where to find them, and how to hook them. And it’s really different.

Kortney Harmon [00:15:35]:
We’re not creating trusting environments. We’re not creating a place for them to feel safe, for us to create those relationships.

Daphne Phalon [00:15:42]:
Right.

Kortney Harmon [00:15:43]:
I agree. So let’s talk about that. So you talked about tech, you talked about automation. As much as I love the idea of speed to get to a conversation, there’s 2 parts of that. I don’t think automation is going away. There are still going to be that group of people that say, what else can I automate? How fast can I get there? What else can I do with this? Are you saying that firms should rip out automation? How should they handle it? Give me your thoughts because There’s a double-edged sword to that.

Daphne Phalon [00:16:13]:
Yeah, there really is a double-edged sword to that. Absolutely right. And no, automation and AI are not going anywhere. In fact, you look down the road and you can only imagine if they’re going this fast now, they’re going faster and faster and faster, and that flywheel will not slow down. Automation absolutely has a role. I mean, I personally benefited from that in my business of like getting kind of the routine stuff off of the plates of my staff and off of my plate. I use AI every single day. So I’m a big proponent of it, but I think that it should be used in a way that amplifies human contact, not replaces it.

Daphne Phalon [00:16:56]:
And the best recruiters that I know in my past and in today use technology to create more time for conversations. For more time with their candidates. And the worst recruiters use it as a substitution for taking the time with their candidates. And the funny part about that is the recruiters that do that, the recruiters that are like, I don’t have to talk to people, I can just send a text blast and I can do that. I can send an email and I— or a text and I can get in touch with 50 people in seconds. Or I can make 50 phone calls to candidates, right? They don’t even realize that they are absolutely making themselves fully replaceable. Because if all we’re doing as a recruiter is doing a gap analysis of this job description and this resume and sending it, then we’re replaceable. That’s the dividing line.

Daphne Phalon [00:17:55]:
So in essence, by cutting those corners, They’re creating an opportunity for AI to just completely replace them. And that’s not what our clients want either, by the way. That’s not— our clients can feel that when recruiters are simply slapping their logo on through AI and kicking a submittal over to see if it sticks. The clients can absolutely feel that. And that’s not what they’re going to be willing to pay a premium for. So we’re undermining ourselves.

Kortney Harmon [00:18:24]:
You talked about All the things that we do as recruiters and how fast we do them and how does that equal what we used to be measured by? So you are like the old of the, the different generation of recruiters. They, they did things differently. It was about relationships. We were also judged on metrics very differently. We knew our submission ratio, interviews to placements, calls to meetings, all of those things.

Daphne Phalon [00:18:48]:
Yeah.

Kortney Harmon [00:18:48]:
How does AI impact metrics? Today, most firms measure, yeah, I would say activity pretty aggressively.

Daphne Phalon [00:18:57]:
Yeah.

Kortney Harmon [00:18:57]:
How does that change? Because when we can send hundreds of text messages or thousands of emails, how does that change what our operations should look like with AI today?

Daphne Phalon [00:19:06]:
A mentor of mine once said to me, and I’m sure somebody famous said it before him, was that which is measured improves. I don’t know who said it originally, but my mentor said it to me. And it stuck. It stuck with me because it was absolutely right. So, like, if we’re only measuring the activity, the busy, the busy of our day, and we’re measuring how many calls were made, how many texts were sent, how many submittals were logged, we’re gonna get more calls, texts, and submittals.

Kortney Harmon [00:19:40]:
Mm-hmm.

Daphne Phalon [00:19:40]:
It doesn’t mean they’re good, right? I’ve personally had recruiters work for me that You know, when you actually kind of like raised an eyebrow, you’re like, well, you made 350 calls last week and didn’t get a single return phone call. Like, what are you saying? Who are you calling? How come every single one is just a voicemail? I don’t know. Like, you can see when you start to look at it. So you don’t just by measuring activity without looking at what that activity is telling us or what is being done to generate that activity, we’re not really necessarily gauging our likelihood of success, right? And so, what we’re seeing is that the recruiters are almost, because they know, I’ve got to make these many phone calls, I’ve got to send this many text messages, they oftentimes, it’s not everywhere. There’s still really, really, really good recruiters out there. And I think the ones that are doing this are just trained to do this. Right? They know they’ve gotta learn this texting platform because they’ve got to send X number of text messages a day. What that text message says may be worth looking at, but what they need to be looking at is, you mentioned some of them, right? Like how many submittals are you sending before you get that filled, before it becomes revenue, right?

Kortney Harmon [00:21:04]:
Mm-hmm.

Daphne Phalon [00:21:04]:
How much time are they spending doing all this busy work? Before they’re actually getting production. And if we looked, shifted to look at production metrics as opposed to activity metrics only, activity metrics, I think, have a place because staffing’s almost like a recipe. And anybody that’s worked for me has probably heard me say this. And so it’s probably like, ah, here she goes again. But is that, you know, we know what the recipe for success is. You have to have activity. Before you can generate success and productivity. So in the beginning, the training on activity metrics, I think, is important, right? You have to make enough phone calls that you get comfortable on the phone.

Daphne Phalon [00:21:50]:
You have to make, have enough times to log information before you get comfortable with that. But it’s almost like it’s become, that’s it. You get trained on activity, you check a box, And you move on. And I think managers are reinforcing that because managers are relying completely on the dashboard. Did they hit their metrics? Check. Move on. Nothing more to talk about in your one-on-one. And yet, slowly but surely, the coaching part of management, the real teaching and leading and managing side of management is slipping away because those managers are also being held to all of these other activity metrics.

Daphne Phalon [00:22:31]:
And it’s not until the P&L suddenly shows a decline in revenue that everyone’s like, what’s happening? And they start getting all critical about things when in all actuality it had been going on for months at that point. So I think that the metrics should be valuable. Pay attention to what you’re measuring. Pay attention, make sure that it’s measuring for success toward the goal that you’re actually working toward. And I think you’ll find that your metrics are much more valuable at that point. I

Kortney Harmon [00:22:59]:
love it. I agree. This is something that I’ve seen from a coaching standpoint so frequently and just missing the mark left and right. I want to get back to the story that you teased at the beginning, the leadership meeting. Let’s revisit that. Tell me what you found. Tell me the challenge that you uncovered whenever you went to this organization.

Daphne Phalon [00:23:20]:
Sure. To reset it, the leadership team’s all in line. They know exactly what the problem is. And they know that they need somebody that’s gonna come in and either fix their ATS for them or help them with their recruiters. Again, they were all aligned, strong job board, recruiters not delivering the revenue, end of story. But there was no visibility into the metrics that we were just talking about. There was no visibility into time to fill, sub-to-fill ratios, longevity on assignment. They didn’t even have clarity into which recruiters were generating the revenue, the gross profit.

Daphne Phalon [00:24:00]:
All they knew is recruiters were just not doing it. And it must be either the system was too hard or the recruiters were just, I don’t know, lazy, failing, whatever. But what we found was actually jaw-dropping to them because we started with the job board. And it turned out that out of the hundreds of jobs they had open on their job board that they were just dying to fill, 85% of those jobs were either stale, closed, or wishful thinking by the sales team. Only 15% of that robust job board that they had was genuinely viable and workable for for the recruiters. And the recruiters, let’s be honest, the recruiters know which jobs are fillable and which ones aren’t, and which ones are gonna be worth their time. So, the recruiters were focusing on those 15, and so, the whole team of recruiters is fighting over the only few handful of jobs that were really good. Tough news to deliver to that senior leadership team, but eye-opening for them because most of their story that they’d been telling themselves Their perception that they believed was their reality was fiction.

Daphne Phalon [00:25:17]:
And once we cleaned it up and we assigned recruiters to the actual gross profit that they were generating and could really truly see where the successes were and where the failures and gaps were, it was pretty clear that some recruiters were underperforming. But there was this group that was supporting the entire company. And those were the ones that were being kind of loud about griping about what was going on. Those were the ones that were being tagged as being negative, as being complainers.

Kortney Harmon [00:25:52]:
Yeah.

Daphne Phalon [00:25:52]:
Those were the ones that were making the point that the leadership should have been looking at, right? And the problem, turns out, was much deeper than operations because the sales team was undelivering. The sales team wasn’t communicating with their clients to know what was real and what was what wasn’t, to know what was filled and what was still open, to know that slowly but surely long-term relationships were deteriorating, and slowly but surely repeat business wasn’t coming back, and no one was paying attention to that. And the kicker, the applicant tracking system that they had is exceptional. It’s one of the best in the industry. They had all of the automations. They had the texting platforms, they had the parsing tools, they had all sorts of bells and whistles to generate their posts and their integrations with all the job boards. They had all of it. They had all of it.

Daphne Phalon [00:26:47]:
It wasn’t the system failing them, it was them failing the system, right? The garbage in, garbage out. And yet their instinct that they were all nodding about was, replace the technology, that’ll fix it. And so, I mean, it’s crazy how sometimes even like really super smart people, people that have been in this industry, people that have been leaders in this industry kind of get comfortable because reports and data used to have to come from somebody in the corporate office, you know, from the financial team or somebody.

Kortney Harmon [00:27:23]:
Yeah.

Daphne Phalon [00:27:23]:
And there was always that opportunity that somebody mistyped a formula, that somebody fat-fingered something. And so there was a little bit of skepticism that came with it. Yeah. But nowadays it’s like, you want the report, you want to check and see if it’s still the same 3 minutes later, just click a button. And so it becomes fact. It becomes fact to people and people stop questioning it. And so that to me is like a glaring example of how We’ve kind of lost sight of our industry and how to be exceptional in our industry. And we’ve become a little bit too reliant and too complacent with what the systems are kicking out for us.

Kortney Harmon [00:28:07]:
I love this. I experienced something similar as a director of learning and development in an organization. And it was, it was merely a little bit different, but it was the idea that talent in chair meant something to the leadership team, where it meant something different to the people that were labeling that in the system. And they were using that as a predictor of future revenue. And it wasn’t even the same part of the candidate sales cycle. They were on different parts, talent in chair. They thought they were ready to be placed. In reality, it was just someone coming into the office to fill out some paperwork.

Kortney Harmon [00:28:38]:
I love that you bring this up because I think some people might look at this to say, well, that’s not common. This person was just an outlier. Do you think this is not as common, or do you think this is more common than people think?

Daphne Phalon [00:28:53]:
I think it’s fairly common. It definitely depends agency to agency, the depth of this problem. It’s really becoming commonplace for people to just accept the data that was spit out of the machine to them.

Kortney Harmon [00:29:10]:
Got it.

Daphne Phalon [00:29:10]:
And, you know, a dashboard is really truly only as honest as the behavior feeding it. So, It can be wrong, and it’s often wrong, especially if the only training people ever got was when they first got hired. And when they got the little popup in the corner of their screen saying, hey, we have this new reporting tool and take this online course, and then you have to sort of figure out how does that work within my agency. And sometimes the human behavior causes a gap there, right? And so I think leadership looks at numbers that feel like a signal, but they’re actually noise. And they really need to look at it a little bit more objectively. They need to question it. They need to have an environment where they can trust that they can question it. And they need to kind of look at, if the system’s saying this and my financials are saying this, Where’s the disconnect? Is there one, right? Maybe there isn’t one, but if there is a disconnect, question it.

Daphne Phalon [00:30:17]:
Question it. If you’re sitting there, if you’re part of that senior leadership team at that company or any company similar to it, and you’re saying, how can we possibly have all of these jobs and still be not producing the profit that we expect? Why? In your example, it’s because They were using the wrong metric to predict future revenue. In staffing, open job orders should be able to translate, if they’re good, to revenue. And if they’re not, ask the questions and make sure that they’re aligning. But I don’t think it’s uncommon. I think it’s actually more common than we want.

Kortney Harmon [00:30:54]:
And I think it probably has its own flavor at each firm. So you did— what about the job orders themselves? Is the quality of the intake holding up?

Daphne Phalon [00:31:03]:
Oh no, I think, you know, much like the human conversation on the recruiter side, I think that job orders aren’t necessarily qualified the way that they have been in the past. And I think there used to be a little bit more focus on that intake conversation. Like, it was a lot of times job orders honestly get sent out through software. They get texted over to you. They get emailed out to 12 different vendors. And you don’t have those conversations, right? You don’t get to find out, like, well, what’s the culture like, right? What’s the— why did the last person leave? What does great look like to you in 90 days, right? These things were valuable because then when the recruiter had that knowledge and they were interviewing somebody, they could really say, whoa, Daphne’s way too high-strung for this super chill manager. Or this culture, this kind of personality is not gonna be a good fit. And without that, they’re left to sourcing blind.

Daphne Phalon [00:32:05]:
They’re left to parsing in the— throwing the job description into their ChatGPT or their system AI and saying, what are the key skills that I need? And does it match these people in the system? And there’s no personality in it. So I think that sales holds the other side of the equation. I think it goes on both sides, and qualifying your job orders will really, really truly help you because it’ll help the recruiters find the person faster. It will help the— the candidate will feel like they’re actually being heard when they’re interviewed for that. The client will be happy because you didn’t throw mud at the wall. You threw somebody that’s got a great personality, and you said it in your write-up saying, hey, By the way, I think Daphne brings a crazy amount of energy and you’re gonna like this, or she might be a little too much for you. I don’t know. And at the end of the day, when you have a better play, a better submittal, you’re gonna have a better likelihood of a placement.

Daphne Phalon [00:33:08]:
And then you’ve got revenue and the recruiter wins and the salesperson wins, the candidate wins, the client wins, the company wins. It’s a win-win-win-win-win. But in the absence of that, We’re just going to be competing against every, anybody else that’s just using a parsing tool. And that’s not really what recruiting’s intended to be.

Kortney Harmon [00:33:27]:
No, I agree. So what you were saying, I believe, is sales, the other side of it is communication is also breaking down the same way in the candidate relationship as it is with the client relationship. But I think that the more the challenge is, is how do firms know what’s happening before it shows up in revenue? Because oftentimes they’re like, That won’t happen to us. That’s not happening here. I know that that’s not a situation we have. How do they realize it? Like, how do they realize it before it comes and impacts their bottom line?

Daphne Phalon [00:33:58]:
Most important things that I would tell people to look for is repeat business. To me, that’s like the canary in the coal mine, right? It’s like, huh, I don’t see anything wrong. I don’t smell anything wrong, but the canary’s dead. So something’s wrong. I think looking at the relationships that you have with your long-term clients, when you start to see long-term client or even newer business, but the repeat business that’s starting to fall off, it’s one of the earliest and most reliable signals for me that something’s wrong operationally. And it’s almost always invisible. Until it’s significant, because it’s super noticeable when you’ve got this high-volume account and all of a sudden, huh, I had 25 orders opened last week, then I have none this week. Obviously, that’s a glaring example, but a lot of times in firms, it’s onesies, twosies, and the recruiters and the sales folks and even the management are so busy, they might not notice that John at ABC Manufacturing didn’t call in an order last week.

Daphne Phalon [00:35:09]:
Or that it’s been a month or two. It just sort of erodes. And clients that aren’t getting the touch time, they aren’t getting that human connection, maybe they just forget to call it into you, right? It might not be anything glaring. It doesn’t always have to be a glaring situation. And it might not be because they had a bad experience. It might be because they didn’t have an experience at all, or they just had a vanilla generic text message checking in. Right. And as that relationship thins out and the jobs just start slowing, that’s when you should be looking at it.

Daphne Phalon [00:35:47]:
And, and so for me, one of the metrics that I would frequently look at, and I do look at with my clients, is looking at month-over-month comparisons by client. Where are we dropping off? Sometimes it’s seasonal, sometimes it’s expected, but sometimes it isn’t. And if you’re not looking for it, you’re not gonna see it. So that’s where I would start.

Kortney Harmon [00:36:08]:
I love it. I think it’s absolutely something that slips through the cracks. Okay. Is there any specific practices that you feel that have maybe disappeared quietly that maybe you want back?

Daphne Phalon [00:36:20]:
Yeah, there’s probably a lot of them, but I think the one thing that I would say is the post-interview debrief, if that’s a way to call it, right? That used to be gold. And I sound like I’m like, back in the day, but what I mean by that is after every interview, a recruiter that makes a phone call to a candidate and asks, hey, how’d it go? What resonated with you? What didn’t? Are you still interested in this job? What’d you learn? Not only are you finding out, is that candidate still interested in Should you be pushing your client to like bring them in for a second interview or what have you? You’re also finding out feedback for your future submittals if this one’s not a fit. So I think that intelligence that you can kind of gain from the post-interview debrief has the opportunity to make you even more successful in front of the client because the client, you can then give the client, be like, hey, listen, this is the feedback that I got. Delicately. And then you get the real recruiter insights so that the next time you’re like, if the client is— and same goes for the client. The client’s saying, you know, this person was kind of a dud. They didn’t keep up on the tour. They didn’t ask any questions.

Daphne Phalon [00:37:40]:
Well, the next time you have somebody, you’re like, you need to keep up with the tour. You need to ask questions, right? You can coach them better for success. But now I feel like candidates are just sort of getting like ranked or getting some sort of disposition code. thrown back into the ATS. Nobody’s learning anything. The next submittal could look exactly the same, cookie cutter. And I’ll add one more is that like, I think match scores and candidate rankings and everything are great, but I think if I could add one thing back in a practice would be that human element of, I don’t wanna say distrust, but truly like distrust of the data. Yeah.

Daphne Phalon [00:38:21]:
Right, is that like, you know, AI confidence is one thing, but we’re not all literate in it and we’re, and we’re kind of chasing the ball. It’s developing faster than we are. And so like, I worry that too much trust on the outputs of our system is causing a problem. Like human judgment is just being sort of put off to the wayside. And so I would say that’s another thing is like, you know, ask questions and be curious and Don’t trust the data at face value. Question it.

Kortney Harmon [00:38:51]:
I love that. So, okay, I have a question. Okay, no, I’m going to ask the question I wanted to ask before I ask you that question, because I feel like I might be beating a punch and I don’t want to. So let’s flip the script. We talk about what’s not working. What are the firms that are getting this right? What are they doing differently?

Daphne Phalon [00:39:08]:
I think they’re doing several things differently. It’s not just one thing. First, I think that we touched on earlier that I think AI and technology should be used to create more space, more space for the relationship. And I think the firms that are doing really, really well are doing exactly that. They’re getting all the junky noise, repetitive, monotonous tasks off of their team to let them dig deeper into like the actual recruiting efforts and the matching of people. I understand light industrial staffing is a very different pace and very different volume of things than skilled manufacturing or engineering or IT, but I think there’s a place for all of that to get the junk off of people’s plates and make room for that. The second is that they’re doing what I was saying as far as questioning their data. They’re looking under the hood and kind of peeling the onion a little bit more to make sure that the jobs that are open are truly open.

Daphne Phalon [00:40:14]:
The candidates that are being fed into the system aren’t just like, check, I added 50 new people to the system. Are they good? Are they good? Are they placeable candidates? And making sure that the pipeline on both sales and recruiting reflects a reality so that leadership can actually plan And account for gross profit and understand predictable outcomes that I think we’re, like we talked about with the metrics, we’re just too based on activity. The third is purely a human thing, a human trait. It’s the management. It’s the coaching aspect of leading and managing people. There’s a big difference between sitting somebody in front of their computer screen and saying, I know this is going to take about 7 hours to get through all these training modules, but by the end of it, you’re going to be awesome, right? That’s a big difference between that and training somebody and taking the time to care and coach them and give them feedback. And I think the agencies that are still Managing as people and coaching for performance and coaching for success, not just checking a box. They went through training.

Daphne Phalon [00:41:38]:
Yes, they did. I think listening to phone calls, hearing people on the floor, listening in when there’s an interview in the next office, giving them feedback on what they could have done better, that matters. And it also matters as far as turnover on the recruiter side because The recruiters are gonna feel a little bit more loyal to you if you’re taking the time to give them coaching. And the last one is just the, that real conversation, having real conversations, the good, the bad, the ugly with your clients and your candidates. And really understanding that it’s in everyone’s best interest if you tell the client that their expectations for this job are unrealistic. the pay rate’s too low, the shifts are too long, John in the next department is a tyrant and no one wants to work with them, and giving them this feedback so that they can be better, but also giving the candidates feedback. What happened on the interview, right? Giving them the feedback that could help them be a better placeable candidate the next time, or getting the genuine conversations that maybe help you not submit junk in the first place, right? So I think those are probably the 4 things that I would say that the best agencies that I’m seeing with, the ones that are like in it for the long haul and really thriving right now in a challenging economy, have those things buttoned down.

Kortney Harmon [00:43:07]:
Do you think, and I, again, I don’t want to put any words in your mouth. I understand this is, this This is essentially what Lucid solves, right? Is you coming in to do that. You have an operations background. Do you think like the operations person is lacking in a lot of these agencies and offices in that role because we haven’t put importance behind it? Or do you think if that’s not the issue?

Daphne Phalon [00:43:34]:
That the operational managers are struggling with it?

Kortney Harmon [00:43:38]:
Yeah, sometimes, I don’t know about you, I see offices not even have an operations role. So like some of things, yeah, you, as you giggle, um, you go by the wayside. And the other piece you also said was almost like a director of learning and development. Again, most things that some people don’t have in their offices. So those are 2 roles. Do you think if they were to have that or have someone like you in that consulting role, that would solve a lot of those problems?

Daphne Phalon [00:44:08]:
I do. And, and the reason I do is that Staffing agencies always, always run lean. They always run lean, right? And so we’ve added this whole thing of like, who’s managing the tech stack, right? That the IT person at many agencies is somebody that’s outsourced to just manage their technology from afar or when there’s a problem. And now we have A situation where we’ve got new tech happening all the time and understanding how the process, the process in your system, in your company is critical. So yes, I think many, many agencies are putting their resources into technology, into adding more recruiters, adding more salespeople, but they’re not putting resources into making sure that they’re all working together. And that there is a process that we can follow that will give us predictable results, that will give us the fastest route to revenue, that will give us the easiest route to revenue while incorporating sales, recruiting, and technology all together. And I think that, you know, having somebody in an operations role in this particular point in time in our industry is really important. And part of that is that we’re not really looking at it as a whole.

Daphne Phalon [00:45:37]:
We oftentimes, just like the client I was using as an example, they were only looking, it’s a recruiting problem, period, end of conversation. And if, where but for not recruiting, it must be technology. And so I think when you have somebody that’s in an operational role that can step back and look at it as a whole, And say, where in this entire process are things working and where are they not working? And how do we create the bridge to get those areas strengthened up? And that, that’s really important in today’s day and age. Now, we talked earlier too about implementing new softwares, new technologies.

Kortney Harmon [00:46:18]:
Yeah.

Daphne Phalon [00:46:19]:
Most agencies don’t have a project manager, like I said earlier, sitting back waiting for the next project to come. And so they waste their money because they end up having things half implemented. So whether it’s through having somebody full-time operationally, if you can have that in your budget and have them be really impacting your revenue and driving your profitability through process improvements, awesome. If you can’t, there’s people like me that can come in and help with a project that can help Look at things objectively to help you see where things may be broken and where you want to focus. And that, I think, is really important in today’s society, in today’s industry. It’s not going away. It’s only going to become more complicated. So might as well get it right now.

Kortney Harmon [00:47:09]:
I love that. So last question to close for the staffing leaders listening right now who may suspect something is happening in their firm. What should they do Monday morning? Maybe next Monday, because today might be a little late. What should they do next Monday morning?

Daphne Phalon [00:47:25]:
Short answer, get honest. Get honest with yourself. And, you know, I think the ones, the firms that are going to do the best in the back half of 2026, and, you know, you said at the beginning, like operations is like a big, a big thing this year for sure. I don’t believe that those agencies are the ones that are going to have the best of the best technology and implement 10 new platforms by the end of the day, by the end of the year. I think technology’s often fine and the tools are often good. The problem is the human behavior and what gets fed into the system. And when that gets ignored, when that gets automated, bad behavior gets automated and replicated and pushed out more and more and more, it can cause a big problem quickly. So look at your dashboard, question your data, question your results.

Daphne Phalon [00:48:19]:
If your profitability is not lining up with what you expect it to be, and yet everybody’s working really hard and all these, you know, new clients are signing and new jobs are opening, question that. Look for areas where there’s, you know, gaps. Or leaks, I should say, in margin leaks. I just, I just did a post on that too, on margin leaks, because there, I mean, there’s all sorts of places a good staffing agency, even the best of staffing agencies, can sometimes look like a colander where it’s just flowing out, leaking all over the place for retaining that profit. So you can’t automate yourself, uh, your way to trust. You have to look at the data and make sure that it’s accurate. And so Monday morning, your Monday morning move is not add another tool. It’s make sure that, you know, take the next 2 weeks.

Daphne Phalon [00:49:14]:
I don’t care. Take the next 2 weeks and really look at what do we already own? What is working? What really isn’t implemented to its fullest and can be improved? Then double down on that and make your current system produce for you as opposed to just adding something else.

Kortney Harmon [00:49:34]:
Great piece of advice. I love this. This is, I’ve been talking about operations in a different sense to some extent since last November, um, and saying this is the gap. And I love that this is where you’re focusing on and this is where you are developing and really honing in, in this industry. I think it’s amazing. I think this conversation was amazing. Daphne, thank you so much for joining us today. And giving your insights to our industry.

Kortney Harmon [00:50:00]:
Now, if people want to connect with you, we will connect— add your LinkedIn profile and Lucent website in the show notes in case they want to reach out and maybe do consulting services with you. Is there anything else they should know?

Daphne Phalon [00:50:12]:
No. I mean, I think the only thing that I would say is that if you’re questioning anything within your process or you want to look to see to have it, if you can find process improvements and really boost your profitability. You know, I’d love to have a conversation with you. Just, it costs you nothing to pick up the phone and call me and to connect with me on LinkedIn. And, you know, it’s, I’m having a blast doing it. Honestly, I’m having a really good time doing it because it’s really rewarding for everyone involved when you can really find some gaps and make those bridges. And it’s been great. So feel free to reach out.

Kortney Harmon [00:50:47]:
I love it. Well, that’s a wrap on today’s conversation. If there’s one thing that we know, it’s Recruiting isn’t standing still, whether it’s with tech, talent trends, leadership, whether you need to navigate your next chapter. If you found value in today’s session or today’s discussion, please connect with Daphne. Be sure to subscribe to the podcast, leave us a review, and someone maybe share it with who’s ready to evolve. Remember, the future of recruiting doesn’t wait. It’s shaped by those who are embracing change. So until next time, let’s keep evolving.

Kortney Harmon [00:51:19]:
The conversation doesn’t end here. Take what challenged you, sparked an idea, or made you think differently and bring it into your next conversation. For more on what’s moving the talent industry forward, follow the Recruiting Evolution Podcast. I’m your host, Kortney Harmon. Stay curious, stay connected, and keep evolving.

Scroll to Top

Your next placement is already in your database.

Most ATSs store your candidates. Crelate’s Living Platform™ activates them – surfacing who’s ready to move, who just got promoted, and who you should be calling today. Stop guessing. Start in minutes.